20230316, 13:41  #1 
May 2022
2^{2}×3^{2} Posts 
Msieve number field sieve polynomial selection failing
Hello, when I attempt to run the command "./msieve <integer> v np", it briefly prints info before terminating with "bus error: ./msieve <integer> v np" with no further info.

20230316, 16:36  #2 
Jun 2012
13·307 Posts 
Best practice is to place <integer> in a flat text file called worktodo.ini in the msieve directory.
See https://www.mersenneforum.org/showpo...0&postcount=12 for advice on improving efficiency and results of poly searching with msieve. I use stage1_norm of 5.5% of default value and stage2_norm of 6% of default value but YMMV. If you are searching for a GNFS poly of a larger composite, say > c180, you should consider using CADO. 
20230316, 16:36  #3 
Sep 2009
5·491 Posts 
That's not enough information for us to tell what's wrong.
Please post all the output you did get, especially the msieve version which should be on the first line of output. Then post whatever ended up in msieve.log and msieve.fb (I am assuming you can write to wherever you are running msieve). And what OS are you running and what sort of system is it? Edit, crossposted with swellman. What he did should work, I just tested it on a c93. Last fiddled with by chris2be8 on 20230316 at 16:38 Reason: crosspost 
20230317, 00:45  #4  
May 2022
100100_{2} Posts 
Quote:


20230317, 00:48  #5  
May 2022
44_{8} Posts 
Quote:
Code:
Msieve v. 1.51 (SVN unknown) Fri Mar 17 08:47:07 2023 random seeds: 7c422c0b 9b5008c6 factoring 278928736249208979543689230453796583940253796839402679583485674358995909409509483756324351678942875362738490985478637875828757264343234325617829811000909487652 (159 digits) searching for 15digit factors P1 stage 2 factor found commencing number field sieve (134digit input) commencing number field sieve polynomial selection polynomial degree: 5 max stage 1 norm: 1.88e+20 max stage 2 norm: 4.06e+18 min Evalue: 3.76e11 poly select deadline: 91784 time limit set to 25.50 CPUhours expecting poly E from 4.50e11 to > 5.17e11 searching leading coefficients from 1 to 60 deadline: 200 CPUseconds per coefficient coeff 12 specialq 1  47493 other 21110  50664 zsh: bus error ./msieve v np "1,60" I attached msieve.log here. I don't see a msieve.fb in the directory. I am on MacOS with Apple M1, ARM64 

20230317, 16:41  #6 
Sep 2009
5×491 Posts 
Thanks, that gives us something to go on.
What you are doing looks reasonable. The thing I suspect is "Apple M1, ARM64". I'm using x86_64 (Intel and AMD CPUs) so you are not running the same code as me. Where did you get the msieve program from? Did you compile it yourself? But this will need help from someone who understands the code. Can you get a core dump or run it under a debugger? 
20230317, 23:09  #7 
Tribal Bullet
Oct 2004
3565_{10} Posts 
v1.51 is pretty old. If you are linking against a modern version of GMP there is a critical bugfix in svn r1033 needed to avoid crashes, this may be what is happening.

20230320, 06:05  #8 
May 2022
2^{2}×3^{2} Posts 
msieve postprocessing seems to exit with the same errors

20230320, 06:08  #9  
May 2022
2^{2}×3^{2} Posts 
Quote:


Thread Tools  
Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Understanding msieve's Polynomial Selection Parametrisation  kruoli  Msieve  4  20230309 20:09 
factmsieve.py does not wait for completion of polynomial selection by msieve  maxal  Msieve  0  20220920 20:38 
Running msieve polynomial selection in parallel?  ryanp  Msieve  9  20191116 19:45 
reduce number of coefficient for polynomial selection with msieve on GPU  aein  Factoring  3  20170225 16:42 
msieve 1.52 with GPU polynomial selection  cgy606  Msieve  16  20161006 14:16 