20100612, 04:44  #1 
1676_{8} Posts 
Can Old PCs Help New PCs on Same Team?
Hi,
A few months ago, a friend recommended the Prime95 program to stresstest the CPU on an old Windows 98 PC. When I looked up the program, I discovered this project and it sounds really cool. Now I'd like to learn a bit more about how the project works. I've looked around the website, but haven't found some of the things I'm looking for, so here I am! I read on the website about "teams" that participate in the search. At the same time, I understand that slower computers are not ideally equipped to perform the lengthy operations that qualify for the available prizes, BUT that there are secondary operations that can be assigned to these older machines. Therefore, I would like to know the following: I have two current (Vista) computers and three really old PCs (Pentium, Pentium II, Pentium III). Is it possible to set up a "team" where the older computers will somehow be directly helping the new machines to win the prize? I won't deny the fact that the cash prize is a big motivating factor here, but I'd like to add that given the odds of actually finding the next large prime number, and the cost of running PCs 24/7, if money were the only factor I'd probably be better off playing the lottery. As I said, this IS a really neat project. It's the combination of the goal plus the prize that got me here. So then, can I set up my old PCs to provide direct assistance to the new PCs in pursuit of the prize by performing the auxiliary operations, or would the old PCs' efforts be going into some general pool of results? If this topic has already been covered, I apologize for any annoyance I've caused, and will appreciate getting pointed to the page with the answer. Thanks very much. Rodrigo 
20100612, 10:13  #2  
"Jacob"
Sep 2006
Brussels, Belgium
3356_{8} Posts 
Quote:
Jacob 

20100612, 22:36  #3 
"Richard B. Woods"
Aug 2002
Wisconsin USA
2^{2}·3·641 Posts 
Rodrigo,
Jacob's correct, but I want to elaborate. Short answer: Your slow computers are relatively useless in pursuit of the money prize. Medium answer: Theoretically, it's possible to design software to divide and assign the subtasks of the money prize pursuit in a way that might allow multiple computers of any speed to contribute, each in proportion to its speed. However, that's not the way the existing software was designed. "Teams" mean something different  each member and computer operates independently, but their achievement totals are added together for competitive ranking purposes. Longer answer: The work coordinated by GIMPS includes several different types of tasks. Only one type (firsttime LucasLehmer tests) is used to pursue the money prize, and that type is best performed on fast systems. All the other work types are valuable from a mathematical point of view. Some of them might earn you a teenytiny bit of fame among mathematicians (i.e., your name could be added to a long list somewhere), but most will simply anonymously contribute to group efforts. They can be great fun for those who love math, but will not earn you any money. If you're still interested (and are prepared for an occasional forum comment from folks who place excessive emphasis on speed), your "slow" systems can usefully perform some of those secondary tasks. Last fiddled with by cheesehead on 20100612 at 22:50 
20100612, 22:39  #4 
3·31·37 Posts 
O.K., I understand. I had visions of taking the old computers out of mothballs to somehow help the new ones, but I guess that's not the way the project works.
Thanks for clarifying that! 
20100613, 00:41  #5  
6809 > 6502
"""""""""""""""""""
Aug 2003
101×103 Posts
10232_{10} Posts 
Quote:
2 types of work are done on numbers before the firsttime LucasLehmer test. They are Trial Factoring and P1 factoring. Trial Factoring can be broken up easily among multiple machines. If you chose to try for the prize money for the first 100 million digit prime, you could get an assignment for an exponent. Likely there would be some TF and P1 work left to do. You could set the older Pentiums to do some/all of the TF while the faster machine does the P1 (or if the PIII has enough memory, have it do that while the fast machine does starts the LL, but this could be a waste). Then after the various bits of factoring are done have the fast machine do the LL. When that happens, you can pick up another number. Have the slow machines work on the factoring while the fast machine works for a year or so on the first number. 

20100613, 05:59  #6 
67×109 Posts 
cheesehead,
Now that there's more than one answer, I'd better start addressing my posts to avoid confusion. Thank you for elaborating on what Jacob said. From reading around the website I did think that the way you explained it was the way the projects works, but I wanted to ask just in case my idea was doable. (And Uncwilly's later reply gives hope.) This is indeed a very interesting project, so if my slow computers actually ended up bogging things down instead of helping, I wouldn't want to use them. Or give grounds for complaints. I don't know for sure yet how things are structured, but in principle I'd think that even a little bit of help from a slow PC should be better than no help from that old PC. Like having an old soldier plugging a hole in the defenses instead of no one. I appreciate your taking the time to explain! Rodrigo 
20100613, 06:12  #7 
3×1,789 Posts 
Uncwilly,
This is what I was hoping for! So you're saying that my slower computers could in fact be assigned to assist my faster ones, by doing some of the simpler prep work for the same prime number? That would be really exciting! I'm going back into the project site to explore the requirements for each type of task, and which versions of the software would work with my respective computers. Hopefully all the PCs I mentioned will be able to contribute. (I also have two ancient Intel 8086/8088 machines, but that's probably pushing it...) Thanks very much. Rodrigo 
20100613, 18:14  #8  
"GIMFS"
Sep 2002
Oeiras, Portugal
10111110100_{2} Posts 
Quote:
Your old PCs (except the 8086/8088) are perfectly usable for Trial Factoring large exponents. You may use them the way Uncwilly described, or you might as well just choose the type of work TFLMH, that will assign large exponents to your machines, that are returned to the pool once factored to the default bit level. You are either way very welcome aboard. Suggestion: register in the forum. Just curious: where are you from? Rodrigo is a portuguese name, although also found in other countries. Last fiddled with by lycorn on 20100613 at 18:15 

20100614, 01:40  #9 
6809 > 6502
"""""""""""""""""""
Aug 2003
101×103 Posts
2^{3}×1,279 Posts 
It would take a Pentium about 6 months to take a number in the 100 million digit range from 72 to 73. This one would be best used by GIMPS in the TFLMH type of work (where it would be looking at lower bit levels.)
The other machines could more practically do the trial factoring while the fast machine does P1, which should take about 1 month (IIRC). If you keep an eye on the machines you can stop them if one finds a factor. But, dividing up the primality test, LL to separate CPU's is not worth doing. There is lots of factoring work needed in the prize money area. (However, the money only gets distributed to those that did the LL test.) 
20100614, 15:04  #10  
If I May
"Chris Halsall"
Sep 2002
Barbados
10011111000101_{2} Posts 
Quote:
As has been noted elsewhere, older machines lose their effectiveness doing TF work above 64 (i.e. 64 > 65 or above). Based on this, it would actually be more cost effective for you (after a period of time) to buy a new machine, taking into consideration work achieved per KWh and your cost per KWh. 

20100615, 01:47  #11 
13×659 Posts 
lycorn,
Yes, if it's possible I would like to use my old computers to assist my new computers in their pursuit of the prize, as Uncwilly described. And to answer your question  I'm not Portuguese, but (if it counts) my grandfather was born in Galicia! :) The weekend was very busy so I didn't get to explore the GIMPS website very well, but I do want to get up to speed on LL, TF, P1 and the rest of the project vocabulary. Then I will feel more comfortable participating in the forum. Thank you! 
Thread Tools  
Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Team name  BrianE  Game 3  ♚♛♝♞♜♟  Morphy's Maniacs  7  20141221 06:16 
Team Spirit  davieddy  Lounge  7  20111010 06:39 
Team PrimeX Factoring Team  louis_net  Teams  9  20041015 22:59 
Where's the Team Stats?  Death  NFSNET Discussion  9  20040612 19:22 
Team stats  Prime95  PrimeNet  15  20031124 15:56 