gpuOwL: an OpenCL program for Mersenne primality testing - Page 235

axn · 2020-11-02, 11:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by M344587487

Allow me to be the pessimistic one.

Sure, it is all speculation, and things might not pan out. However, even if power efficiency is not there but raw performance is, it still might be worth it for GIMPS (compared to the general stagnation in (intel) CPU and (nvidia) GPU)

Quote:

Originally Posted by M344587487

I still maintain that the types of gamer who bought R7 will want to upgrade to big navi so there may be a glut of them on the secondhand market. If big navi doesn't perform for compute or uses too much power to do so then hoovering up R7's is a good plan B.

I believe there are a total of 5000 R7's ever made. So not sure how much will be available, come RX 6000 wide availability. Nonetheless, definitely pick one up if you see one at a reasonable price

Quote:

Originally Posted by M344587487

Of big navi 6800XT is the one to get, 8 extra CU's and a better bin are likely not worth $350 but $70 for 12 extra CU's seems like a no-brainer.

Agreed, 6800XT appears to be the sweet spot. In fact, a kick ass all-AMD setup with 5900X + 6800XT could be a monster GIMPS platform.

aheeffer · 2020-11-02, 12:11

I am glad I cancelled my RTX 3080 order. It really disappoints with 1990µsec/it for a 77M exponent. I acguired a Radeon Vega 64 a few days ago at 240 € and I get 1970µsec/it for a 109M exponent. Since my 5 x Radeon VII rig runs at full capacity now, I decided to change strategy and built a cheaper rig using Radeon Vega 64 cards. This is my configuration and price:

GPUOWL rig at 800 Ghz-d/d and 24 kwh/d

Asrock H110 Pro BTC+ ------ 70 €
Intel i3-7100 + cooler ---- 90 €
Geil 2 x 8 GB DDR4 3200 --- 60 €
Kingston 500 MB nvme SSD -- 55 €
6-pack PCIe risers (China)- 15 €
5 x Arctic F12 fans ------- 16 €
Yongse miner case --------- 130 €
Corsair HX 1200i ---------- 289 €

Total mining case --------- 725 €

5 x Radeon Vega 64 -------- 1200 €

I currently have only one Vega 64, but I picked up another Radeon VII at 510 € at a local 2nd hands site. I am waiting patiently for more used cards to come to the market. With the HX1200i I think I can go to 5 cards. I can clock the Vega 64 down with Radeon Adrenalin to 165 W, running 71°C with an acceptable 2010 µsec/it for a 109M exponent.

kriesel · 2020-11-02, 13:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by M344587487

Of big navi 6800XT is the one to get, 8 extra CU's and a better bin are likely not worth $350 but $70 for 12 extra CU's seems like a no-brainer.

Another way to put that is for about the same money, 2x6900XT or 3x6800XT,
2 x 80 CU vs 3x72 CU, miners and GIMPSters will go for the 6800XT big time.

M344587487 · 2020-11-02, 14:01

Big Navi may not be a good choice for mining, Ethereum and Monero both need random access to multi-gigabyte data so the infinity cache may only be marginally useful making Navi 1 a better choice. I've been out of the mining loop for years, but last I knew they were the main coins worth mining with everything else trailing massively. 95% of coins were only worth mining for their spot price, with luck the hype and opportunism that plagued mining back then and fueled a lot of the altcoins reason for existing has diminished.

The 6800 CU/$ isn't too much worse than the 6800XT so I wouldn't sweat resorting to the 6800 if supply is low.

DrobinsonPE · 2020-11-04, 05:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrobinsonPE

I saw your post and thought it would be an interesting experiment to try gpuowl on my Celeron J4105 with UHD 600 integrated graphics. I got mfakto working on it so why not try gpuowl as well. It looks like it failed on the OpenCL version.

I did a little investigation and discovered one of the reasons why GPUOWL will not work on UHD 600.

Even though UHD 600 supports OpenCL 2.1

https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-spec...hics-600.c3065

The current Windows 10 driver only supports OpenCL 1.2 for the UHD 600. See page 4 of this document.

https://downloadmirror.intel.com/299...s_100.8853.pdf

moebius · 2020-11-04, 23:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by moebius

The Radeon Instinct MI 100 with CDNA architecture (Release 2020) then actually has a memory bandwidth of 1229 GB/s and 32 GB HBM2 and 4.098 TFlops FP 64, but is of course from the professional sector and unaffordable. I think only the A100 will compete with it.
https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-spec...ct-mi100.c3496

The launch is likely to be on November 16, 2020 but with up to 12.5 TFLOPs FP64?
https://wccftech.com/amd-instinct-mi...ches-november/

axn · 2020-11-05, 04:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by moebius

The launch is likely to be on November 16, 2020 but with up to 12.5 TFLOPs FP64?
https://wccftech.com/amd-instinct-mi...ches-november/

While it will be a nice card with probably A100-like performance, it will be priced similarly too. It'd be interesting if there is a "Radeon Pro" equivalent.

LaurV · 2020-11-05, 09:06

re 3080/3090: Yeah, baby! More and cheaper 2080Ti's for me in the future, when the kids will sell them for peanuts to buy "the new fashion cards" for their gaming rigs... (didn't I say that?

Listen to the old salt next time!).

Thanks Oliver for benchmarks.

@axn re Radeon Pro: there is a Pro VII that can be bought from bandh, quite expensive, and I don't think is so much more performant than a "classic" VII to worth the money difference.

axn · 2020-11-05, 12:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by LaurV

@axn re Radeon Pro: there is a Pro VII that can be bought from bandh, quite expensive, and I don't think is so much more performant than a "classic" VII to worth the money difference.

Yes. But presumably, AMD will keep making next generation "CDNA" Pros while Radeon VIIs are only available in (ever shrinking) secondhand market.

DrobinsonPE · 2020-11-09, 05:11

moebius,

This one is for you. Ryzen 3 3200G APU.

Code:

2020-11-08 20:18:24 gpuowl v6.11-380-g79ea0cc
2020-11-08 20:18:24 config: -iters 200000 -prp 77936867
2020-11-08 20:18:24 gfx902-0 77936867 FFT: 4M 1K:8:256 (18.58 bpw)
2020-11-08 20:18:27 gfx902-0 OpenCL compilation in 2.85 s
2020-11-08 20:18:32 gfx902-0 Proof using power 8
2020-11-08 20:18:46 gfx902-0 77936867 OK      800   0.00%; 11081 us/it; ETA 9d 23:54; 1579c241dc63eca6 (check 4.48s)
2020-11-08 20:55:27 gfx902-0 Stopping, please wait..
2020-11-08 20:55:36 gfx902-0 77936867 OK   200000   0.26%; 11071 us/it; ETA 9d 23:03; f0b04b45b0855bd2 (check 4.48s)
2020-11-08 20:55:36 gfx902-0 Exiting because "stop requested"
2020-11-08 20:55:36 gfx902-0 Bye

M344587487 · 2020-11-09, 11:48

Nice that you got it working. What is your set up, simply the latest ROCm on Mint 20 like you used elsewhere?

2020-11-02, 12:11	#2576
aheeffer Aug 2020 37 Posts	New gpu rig with excelent price/performance I am glad I cancelled my RTX 3080 order. It really disappoints with 1990µsec/it for a 77M exponent. I acguired a Radeon Vega 64 a few days ago at 240 € and I get 1970µsec/it for a 109M exponent. Since my 5 x Radeon VII rig runs at full capacity now, I decided to change strategy and built a cheaper rig using Radeon Vega 64 cards. This is my configuration and price: GPUOWL rig at 800 Ghz-d/d and 24 kwh/d Asrock H110 Pro BTC+ ------ 70 € Intel i3-7100 + cooler ---- 90 € Geil 2 x 8 GB DDR4 3200 --- 60 € Kingston 500 MB nvme SSD -- 55 € 6-pack PCIe risers (China)- 15 € 5 x Arctic F12 fans ------- 16 € Yongse miner case --------- 130 € Corsair HX 1200i ---------- 289 € Total mining case --------- 725 € 5 x Radeon Vega 64 -------- 1200 € I currently have only one Vega 64, but I picked up another Radeon VII at 510 € at a local 2nd hands site. I am waiting patiently for more used cards to come to the market. With the HX1200i I think I can go to 5 cards. I can clock the Vega 64 down with Radeon Adrenalin to 165 W, running 71°C with an acceptable 2010 µsec/it for a 109M exponent.

2020-11-05, 09:06	#2582
LaurV Romulan Interpreter Jun 2011 Thailand 21701₈ Posts	re 3080/3090: Yeah, baby! More and cheaper 2080Ti's for me in the future, when the kids will sell them for peanuts to buy "the new fashion cards" for their gaming rigs... (didn't I say that? Listen to the old salt next time!). Thanks Oliver for benchmarks. @axn re Radeon Pro: there is a Pro VII that can be bought from bandh, quite expensive, and I don't think is so much more performant than a "classic" VII to worth the money difference. Last fiddled with by LaurV on 2020-11-05 at 09:09

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
mfakto: an OpenCL program for Mersenne prefactoring	Bdot	GPU Computing	1668	2020-12-22 15:38
GPUOWL AMD Windows OpenCL issues	xx005fs	GpuOwl	0	2019-07-26 21:37
Testing an expression for primality	1260	Software	17	2015-08-28 01:35
Testing Mersenne cofactors for primality?	CRGreathouse	Computer Science & Computational Number Theory	18	2013-06-08 19:12
Primality-testing program with multiple types of moduli (PFGW-related)	Unregistered	Information & Answers	4	2006-10-04 22:38

2020-11-02, 14:01	#2578
M344587487 "Composite as Heck" Oct 2017 3·5·7² Posts	Big Navi may not be a good choice for mining, Ethereum and Monero both need random access to multi-gigabyte data so the infinity cache may only be marginally useful making Navi 1 a better choice. I've been out of the mining loop for years, but last I knew they were the main coins worth mining with everything else trailing massively. 95% of coins were only worth mining for their spot price, with luck the hype and opportunism that plagued mining back then and fueled a lot of the altcoins reason for existing has diminished. The 6800 CU/$ isn't too much worse than the 6800XT so I wouldn't sweat resorting to the 6800 if supply is low.

2020-11-09, 11:48	#2585
M344587487 "Composite as Heck" Oct 2017 3×5×7² Posts	Nice that you got it working. What is your set up, simply the latest ROCm on Mint 20 like you used elsewhere?