mersenneforum.org  

Go Back   mersenneforum.org > Great Internet Mersenne Prime Search > Data > Marin's Mersenne-aries

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools
Old 2018-01-24, 22:19   #1640
Madpoo
Serpentine Vermin Jar
 
Madpoo's Avatar
 
Jul 2014

63238 Posts
Default New list

I haven't done an updated "potentially bad" list in a while, so here goes. Top 100 by their bad/good ratio, then re-sorted by exponent size:

Code:
exponent	Bad	Good	Unk	worktodo
43907971	1	1	1	DoubleCheck=43907971,72,1
45210229	1	0	3	DoubleCheck=45210229,73,1
45270061	1	0	3	DoubleCheck=45270061,73,1
45554557	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=45554557,73,1
45639227	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=45639227,73,1
45771151	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=45771151,73,1
46041311	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=46041311,73,1
46326053	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=46326053,73,1
46480969	2	3	3	DoubleCheck=46480969,73,1
46481797	2	3	3	DoubleCheck=46481797,73,1
46731457	1	1	2	DoubleCheck=46731457,75,1
46880387	2	0	2	DoubleCheck=46880387,73,1
46893641	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=46893641,73,1
47164939	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=47164939,73,1
47186539	1	1	2	DoubleCheck=47186539,73,1
47236151	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=47236151,73,1
47294899	1	1	2	DoubleCheck=47294899,73,1
49481087	3	4	2	DoubleCheck=49481087,73,1
49883291	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=49883291,73,1
50331461	1	1	1	DoubleCheck=50331461,73,1
50391623	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=50391623,73,1
50461591	1	1	3	DoubleCheck=50461591,73,1
50745581	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=50745581,73,1
51774959	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=51774959,73,1
51783289	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=51783289,73,1
51867259	1	1	3	DoubleCheck=51867259,73,1
51968027	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=51968027,73,1
51987197	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=51987197,73,1
52009949	1	1	9	DoubleCheck=52009949,73,1
52012523	1	1	9	DoubleCheck=52012523,73,1
52012553	1	1	9	DoubleCheck=52012553,73,1
52162093	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52162093,73,1
52242319	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=52242319,73,1
52316051	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52316051,73,1
52433503	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52433503,73,1
52451279	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52451279,73,1
52500229	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52500229,73,1
52582693	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52582693,73,1
52582697	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52582697,73,1
52731869	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=52731869,73,1
52751147	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=52751147,73,1
52852691	1	1	9	DoubleCheck=52852691,73,1
53036561	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=53036561,73,1
53149091	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=53149091,73,1
53155153	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=53155153,73,1
53625107	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=53625107,73,1
53627617	2	3	6	DoubleCheck=53627617,73,1
53669309	2	3	6	DoubleCheck=53669309,73,1
53691199	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=53691199,73,1
53693557	2	3	6	DoubleCheck=53693557,73,1
53926087	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=53926087,73,1
54451681	1	0	3	DoubleCheck=54451681,73,1
54468013	1	1	3	DoubleCheck=54468013,73,1
54469427	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=54469427,73,1
54538031	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=54538031,73,1
54539983	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=54539983,73,1
54586663	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=54586663,73,1
54698923	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=54698923,74,1
54852011	2	2	4	DoubleCheck=54852011,73,1
54852407	2	2	4	DoubleCheck=54852407,73,1
55100491	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=55100491,73,1
55448333	1	1	10	DoubleCheck=55448333,73,1
55571273	2	1	5	DoubleCheck=55571273,73,1
55588213	2	1	5	DoubleCheck=55588213,73,1
55588349	2	1	5	DoubleCheck=55588349,73,1
55607131	2	1	5	DoubleCheck=55607131,73,1
55633783	2	1	5	DoubleCheck=55633783,73,1
55776619	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=55776619,74,1
55797523	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=55797523,74,1
55818923	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=55818923,74,1
55829551	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=55829551,74,1
55962287	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=55962287,74,1
56019877	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=56019877,74,1
56217779	1	1	9	DoubleCheck=56217779,73,1
56221273	1	1	9	DoubleCheck=56221273,73,1
56365151	2	3	1	DoubleCheck=56365151,73,1
56655779	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=56655779,73,1
56691853	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=56691853,73,1
56699003	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=56699003,73,1
56750671	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=56750671,73,1
56829193	1	1	4	DoubleCheck=56829193,73,1
56849263	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=56849263,73,1
56857217	1	1	3	DoubleCheck=56857217,73,1
57239123	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57239123,74,1
57285229	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57285229,74,1
57307457	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57307457,74,1
57321293	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57321293,74,1
57363377	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57363377,74,1
57408977	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57408977,74,1
57427057	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57427057,74,1
57454099	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=57454099,74,1
58885549	1	1	6	DoubleCheck=58885549,74,1
59153929	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=59153929,74,1
59211871	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=59211871,74,1
59219011	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=59219011,74,1
59429039	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=59429039,74,1
59528437	1	1	5	DoubleCheck=59528437,74,1
59648437	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=59648437,74,1
59856241	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=59856241,74,1
59939849	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=59939849,74,1
Madpoo is offline  
Old 2018-01-24, 22:52   #1641
cuBerBruce
 
cuBerBruce's Avatar
 
Aug 2012
Mass., USA

1001111102 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Madpoo View Post
I haven't done an updated "potentially bad" list in a while, so here goes. Top 100 by their bad/good ratio, then re-sorted by exponent size:

Code:
exponent	Bad	Good	Unk	worktodo
43907971	1	1	1	DoubleCheck=43907971,72,1
45210229	1	0	3	DoubleCheck=45210229,73,1
45270061	1	0	3	DoubleCheck=45270061,73,1
45554557	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=45554557,73,1
I took these first four.
cuBerBruce is offline  
Old 2018-01-25, 02:03   #1642
Prime95
P90 years forever!
 
Prime95's Avatar
 
Aug 2002
Yeehaw, FL

23×11×83 Posts
Default

Excellent timing. I took the next 12:

Code:
45639227	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=45639227,73,1
45771151	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=45771151,73,1
46041311	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=46041311,73,1
46326053	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=46326053,73,1
46480969	2	3	3	DoubleCheck=46480969,73,1
46481797	2	3	3	DoubleCheck=46481797,73,1
46731457	1	1	2	DoubleCheck=46731457,75,1
46880387	2	0	2	DoubleCheck=46880387,73,1
46893641	1	0	1	DoubleCheck=46893641,73,1
47164939	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=47164939,73,1
47186539	1	1	2	DoubleCheck=47186539,73,1
47236151	1	1	8	DoubleCheck=47236151,73,1
Prime95 is online now  
Old 2018-01-27, 07:24   #1643
ixfd64
Bemusing Prompter
 
ixfd64's Avatar
 
"Danny"
Dec 2002
California

2,351 Posts
Default

Silly question: do these lists include exponents tested by computers with bad P-1 results?

If a computer has missed a P-1 factor, then I imagine it's likely to return bad LL results as well.
ixfd64 is offline  
Old 2018-01-27, 10:30   #1644
kruoli
 
kruoli's Avatar
 
"Oliver"
Sep 2017
Porta Westfalica, DE

11·37 Posts
Default

Some of them are at least missing stage 2 of P-1.

Madpoo, can you generate a list of those which are missing stage 2? Then I'll do all of them. I'll start a single run of 4948107.
kruoli is online now  
Old 2018-01-28, 18:50   #1645
Madpoo
Serpentine Vermin Jar
 
Madpoo's Avatar
 
Jul 2014

72·67 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ixfd64 View Post
Silly question: do these lists include exponents tested by computers with bad P-1 results?

If a computer has missed a P-1 factor, then I imagine it's likely to return bad LL results as well.
There's really no easy way for me to look at a P-1 result and say with any certainty "this guy missed finding a factor".

Then again, not many people are doing P-1 work so it might not be that useful anyway.
Madpoo is offline  
Old 2018-01-28, 19:46   #1646
chalsall
If I May
 
chalsall's Avatar
 
"Chris Halsall"
Sep 2002
Barbados

222728 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Madpoo View Post
Then again, not many people are doing P-1 work so it might not be that useful anyway.
I would disagree with this statement.

Some people are doing a *serious* amount of P-1 work. There is a reason no LL assignments have been handed out which need P-1 work done for several years now.
chalsall is online now  
Old 2018-01-28, 20:45   #1647
chalsall
If I May
 
chalsall's Avatar
 
"Chris Halsall"
Sep 2002
Barbados

2×3×1,567 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kruoli View Post
Some of them are at least missing stage 2 of P-1. Madpoo, can you generate a list of those which are missing stage 2? Then I'll do all of them. I'll start a single run of 4948107.
Just so you know, James' mersenne.ca site proves such information. Please see this query for example.

Some of the more anally retentive of us are currently doing P-1 work in the lower ranges with better parameters, so please try to avoid duplication of work.
chalsall is online now  
Old 2018-01-28, 23:53   #1648
ixfd64
Bemusing Prompter
 
ixfd64's Avatar
 
"Danny"
Dec 2002
California

2,351 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Madpoo View Post
There's really no easy way for me to look at a P-1 result and say with any certainty "this guy missed finding a factor".
James has a page that lists factors missed by P-1: http://mersenne.ca/p1missed.php
ixfd64 is offline  
Old 2018-01-29, 07:02   #1649
LaurV
Romulan Interpreter
 
LaurV's Avatar
 
Jun 2011
Thailand

217018 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Madpoo View Post
There's really no easy way for me to look at a P-1 result and say with any certainty "this guy missed finding a factor".
People, people, wait a moment, there is a confusion here.

kruoli asked for a list of exponents with missing stage 2, not missing factors (this nobody knows, until a "missed" factor is found, by a subsequent run, and not many people re-run P-1 -- I guess that is what Madpoo wanted t say). ixfd64 pointed to a list of missing factors, which is irrelevant for the discussion (it was not asked for, and even if it should have been requested, it is useless for the goal, the man just wants a list with missing stage 2 thingies, most probably to try running stage 2 by himself, and get some nice factors, with cudaPM1 or so).

The list is easy to generate, put into it all exponents where B1==B2, or (in an extended sense) where B2/B1<20 (arbitrary number 20, usually, with a proper stage 2 done, B2 will be 30, 50 or 100 or 500 times larger than B1, depending what you use for the two stages).

The list already exists on James' site, just do the proper query (for example, I used to re-work with CudaPM1 exponents where less than 5% chance to find a factor was done).

So, Madpoo, can you drop a list where (say) B2/B1<xxx ? It may be useful for some of us (or not).

Last fiddled with by LaurV on 2018-01-29 at 07:07
LaurV is offline  
Old 2018-01-29, 07:09   #1650
Dubslow
Basketry That Evening!
 
Dubslow's Avatar
 
"Bunslow the Bold"
Jun 2011
40<A<43 -89<O<-88

3×29×83 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by LaurV View Post
People, people, wait a moment, there is a confusion here.

kruoli asked for a list of exponents with missing stage 2, not missing factors (this nobody knows, until a "missed" factor is found, by a subsequent run, and not many people re-run P-1 -- I guess that is what Madpoo wanted t say). ixfd64 pointed to a list of missing factors, which is irrelevant for the discussion (it was not asked for,
But it was asked for, by ixfd64 himself (1643), before kruoli made his own comment (1644).
Dubslow is offline  
Closed Thread

Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Double-Double Arithmetic Mysticial Software 50 2017-10-30 19:16
Clicking an exponent leads to 404 page marigonzes Information & Answers 2 2017-02-14 16:56
x.265 half the size, double the computation; so if you double again? 1/4th? jasong jasong 7 2015-08-17 10:56
What about double-checking TF/P-1? 137ben PrimeNet 6 2012-03-13 04:01
Double the area, Double the volume. Uncwilly Puzzles 8 2006-07-03 16:02

All times are UTC. The time now is 16:33.

Fri Jan 22 16:33:47 UTC 2021 up 50 days, 12:45, 0 users, load averages: 1.66, 2.06, 2.04

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

This forum has received and complied with 0 (zero) government requests for information.

Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation.
A copy of the license is included in the FAQ.