20221206, 15:03  #2685  
Serpentine Vermin Jar
Jul 2014
2·3·13·43 Posts 
Quote:


20221207, 00:03  #2686 
Dec 2022
5_{16} Posts 
If you need one to examine the nonpublic information, try M9891151 which has a bogus 'ECM' factor followed by a real ECM factor a week later. The problem is also easily seen when seeing the list of TJAOI submissions on 'recent results', or on mersenne.ca where I found it.

20221207, 16:37  #2687  
Serpentine Vermin Jar
Jul 2014
110100011010_{2} Posts 
Quote:
TJAOI uses some custom code to find factors and are not typically assigned, so there's no information on what actual method was used to find it (ECM, TF, etc). The raw result line that was submitted is literally just this: M9891151 has a factor: 222093838040213055689 I don't know if this answers your question or not, but I think that's all that's happening. We have no way of knowing independently how these factors were found so it's just a basic categorization based on exponent size. Again, I'll defer to George (or James might know also) on if I'm right about that. ^^^ I just dug into the code and I'm pretty sure I followed the threads correctly and the threshold for "unknown" factors like that will assume ECM up to 16M if the # of bits in the factor is > 55. If the # of bits is <=55 then it assumes TF although honestly, I wouldn't expect we'd find any more of those. I mean, it'd be nice if TJAOI's code would include the basic details that other clients do, like if it's doing TF, include the bits from/to, and if it's ECM include the bounds, etc. but a factor is a factor. EDIT: While I'm at it, I'll point out that if the factor is for an exponent above 16M, there's a lookup table that sets the cutoff level between P1 and TF based on the exponent size and the current work on where TF bit levels are at. The code will lookup the exponent, find the current set point for TF work and if the factor is below that bit length, it assumes TF, and if above, it assumes P1 with B1=800000. Again, this is just a basic assumption when the client didn't provide any information on how the factor was found. Primenet will guess and dump it into TF, ECM, or P1 as a best guess. Last fiddled with by Madpoo on 20221207 at 16:50 

Thread Tools  
Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Official "Faits erronés dans de belleslettres" thread  ewmayer  Lounge  39  20150519 01:08 
Official "allGreektome Fiction Literature and Cinema" Thread  ewmayer  Science & Technology  41  20140416 11:54 
Official "Lasciate ogne speranza" whingethread  cheesehead  Soap Box  56  20130629 01:42 
Official "Ernst is a deceiving bully and George is a meanie" thread  cheesehead  Soap Box  61  20130611 04:30 
Official "String copy Statement Considered Harmful" thread  Dubslow  Programming  19  20120531 17:49 