GTX 1080 ... which is recommended...

petrw1 · 2017-09-18, 17:41

For TF; or LL; maybe for ECM; or P-1?

I'm hoping in general it is the same card.

When I look on www.newegg.ca (and exclude several out of stock) I see prices (CAN$) between $930 and $1,112 (not a big gap).

I have a note from a 5 months ago (from some mersenne.ca specs) that this was a leader then:

ASUS ROG STRIX GeForce® GTX 1080 TI 11GB OC Edition VR Ready 5K HD Gaming HDMI DisplayPort DVI Overclocked PC Graphics Card" (P/N ROG-STRIX-GTX1080TI-O11G-GAMING).

.... OR ....

is GTX-1080 yesterdays news :)

ATH · 2017-09-18, 19:50

All of them has only DP performance at 1/32 of SP, so they will not be super for LL. They are so fast though, so they are still semi-decent I think? But it might be considered a "waste" using them for LL and "wasting" that high SP performance.

kladner · 2017-09-18, 21:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by ATH

All of them has only DP performance at 1/32 of SP, so they will not be super for LL. They are so fast though, so they are still semi-decent I think? But it might be considered a "waste" using them for LL and "wasting" that high SP performance.

My GTX 1060, running CUDALucas, is a bit faster than 2 i7-6700K cores, running p95. The 1060 is over twice as fast as the GTX 460, with the same, or less, power consumption. All these devices are overclocked. All are running Cat 3 DCs, fairly close to each other.

petrw1 · 2017-09-18, 23:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by ATH

All of them has only DP performance at 1/32 of SP, so they will not be super for LL. They are so fast though, so they are still semi-decent I think? But it might be considered a "waste" using them for LL and "wasting" that high SP performance.

So much better suited for TF...that where I'd most likely use it anyway.

If for TF is this a top card?

Mark Rose · 2017-09-19, 00:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by petrw1

So much better suited for TF...that where I'd most likely use it anyway.

If for TF is this a top card?

The GTX 1080 is excellent for TF. The 1080 Ti would be better (and a lot more expensive), but the 1080 is awesome.

And due to the GTX 1070 being better for Ethereum mining, the GTX 1080 actually has better price/performance for TF right now.

ATH · 2017-09-19, 02:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by petrw1

So much better suited for TF...that where I'd most likely use it anyway.

If for TF is this a top card?

Yes, at ~ 8.2 TLOPS it is only topped in the "normal" graphic cards category by 1080 Ti at 10.6 TFLOPS, Titan X at 10.1 and Titan Xp at 10.8:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GeForce_10_series

and by a few of the crazy Tesla's:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nvidia_Tesla

LaurV · 2017-09-22, 13:06

The 1080 is quite good for TF, but also good, more than decent, for LL.
See Jame's LL table, it is just a bit below a Titan, and it is like two 580s put together, for a fraction of power. And it is actually the first at LL by "JVR" value, which means that, with the electricity price in your area, you will be on the "profit side" in less than a year.

Edit, and as the winter comes, are you heating your house with electricity? Then buy few more... hehe... Oh sorry, you didn't know the winter is coming... in that part of the world is always winter...

Edit 2: Hey James, BTW, you sort that table by price... lexicographic on 4 characters. Since the price of some cards went into $10k, that cards appear between cards with price $900 and cards with price $1100. Please fix it.

storm5510 · 2017-09-23, 05:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by petrw1

When I look on www.newegg.ca (and exclude several out of stock) I see prices (CAN$) between $930 and $1,112 (not a big gap).

ASUS GeForce GTX 1080 8GB ROG STRIX Graphics Card (STRIX-GTX1080-A8G-GAMING) at Amazon is $559 US.

James Heinrich · 2017-09-23, 14:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by LaurV

Hey James, BTW, you sort that table by price... lexicographic on 4 characters. Since the price of some cards went into $10k, that cards appear between cards with price $900 and cards with price $1100. Please fix it.

It was actually being sorted on sprintf("%09.4f", $price) which meant, as you eloquently said, "lexicographic on 4 characters". I have fixed that to %010.2f which should be good up to <$1M.

Quote:

Originally Posted by LaurV

... in that part of the world is always winter...

That's usually true here, but we're having a fantastic beginning-of-autumn heat wave, today is 32°C (feels like 39°C with humidity). The other half of the country has seen snow already last week

LaurV · 2017-09-23, 16:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by James Heinrich

which should be good up to <$1M.

Yarrr

, eager to see the $1M GPUs... Maybe you know something we do not know

Thanks for fixing it.

VictordeHolland · 2017-10-04, 14:47

I'm also in the market for a new GPU for:
- TF
- The occasional DoubleCheck
- Racing games (Project Cars, F1 2016)
- Roleplay/lounge games (Elder Scrolls, Kerbal Space Program)

I'd like to get an ASUS card again, since I've had several years of good experience with them (a GTX470, GTX580, two HD7950 and a ROG Matrix 280X)

Preferably I'd like to order it on a reliable hardware webshop in the Netherlands, that have them in store (Coolblue.nl and Azerty come to mind first), even if that means paying 10 or 20 euro extra.

This would be the prices:

ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1060 - €389
https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/5673...6g-gaming.html

ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1070 - €519
https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/5479...8g-gaming.html

ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1080 - €633
https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/5648...8g-gaming.html

ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1080ti - €839
https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/7499...1g-gaming.html

Expected TF GHzdays/d (from http://www.mersenne.ca/mfaktc.php)
GTX1060 - 459
GTX1070 - 689
GTX1080 - 980
GTX1080ti - 1263

CUDA cores
GTX1060 - 1280
GTX1070 - 1920
GTX1080 - 2560
GTX1080ti - 3584

Memory Bandwidth
GTX1060 - 192 GB/s
GTX1070 - 256 GB/s
GTX1080 - 320 GB/s
GTX1080ti - 484 GB/s

TDP (W)
GTX1060 - 120
GTX1070 - 150
GTX1080 - 180
GTX1080ti - 250

GHzdayd / TDP(W)
GTX1060 - 3.8
GTX1070 - 4.6
GTX1080 - 5.4
GTX1080ti - 5.1

Energy costs per kWh (in €)
0.06280 + 0.12257 + 0.00895 = 0.19432 (at night 23:00-07:00)
0.08069 + 0.12257 + 0.00895 = 0.21221 (rest of the day)
(0.19432* 8 hours + 0.21221 * 16hours) / 24 hours = 0.206246

2 year running cost electricity (TDP/1000*0.206246*24*365*2years)
GTX1060 - 433.61
GTX1070 - 542.02
GTX1080 - 650.42
GTX1080ti - 903.36
Already owned:
ASUS HD7950 - 505.88
ASUS GTX580 - 881.68

GHzdays per day / Total Cost (initial cost+ 2y electricity)
GTX1060 - 459 / (389 + 433.61) = 0.558
GTX1070 - 689 / (519 + 542.02) = 0.649
GTX1080 - 980 / (633 + 650.42) = 0.763
GTX1080ti - 1263 / (839 + 903.36) = 0.725
Already owned:
ASUS HD7950 - 308 / (0+ 505.88) = 0.609
ASUS GTX580 - 433 / (0 + 881.68) = 0.491

So the GTX1060 is not really a good option, since my already owned HD7950 outperforms it in terms of GHzdays/€ . I've stopped running the GTX580 for some time now and these numbers support that decision. The GTX1080 has the best performance/€ on paper followed by the GTX1080ti. I probably don't really need the performance of a 1080(ti) for the games I play, but at least I can now justify spending the extra money

.

2017-09-18, 17:41	#1
petrw1 1976 Toyota Corona years forever! "Wayne" Nov 2006 Saskatchewan, Canada 149C₁₆ Posts	GTX 1080 ... which is recommended... For TF; or LL; maybe for ECM; or P-1? I'm hoping in general it is the same card. When I look on www.newegg.ca (and exclude several out of stock) I see prices (CAN$) between $930 and $1,112 (not a big gap). I have a note from a 5 months ago (from some mersenne.ca specs) that this was a leader then: ASUS ROG STRIX GeForce® GTX 1080 TI 11GB OC Edition VR Ready 5K HD Gaming HDMI DisplayPort DVI Overclocked PC Graphics Card" (P/N ROG-STRIX-GTX1080TI-O11G-GAMING). .... OR .... is GTX-1080 yesterdays news :)

2017-09-22, 13:06	#7
LaurV Romulan Interpreter "name field" Jun 2011 Thailand 3·23·149 Posts	The 1080 is quite good for TF, but also good, more than decent, for LL. See Jame's LL table, it is just a bit below a Titan, and it is like two 580s put together, for a fraction of power. And it is actually the first at LL by "JVR" value, which means that, with the electricity price in your area, you will be on the "profit side" in less than a year. Edit, and as the winter comes, are you heating your house with electricity? Then buy few more... hehe... Oh sorry, you didn't know the winter is coming... in that part of the world is always winter... Edit 2: Hey James, BTW, you sort that table by price... lexicographic on 4 characters. Since the price of some cards went into $10k, that cards appear between cards with price $900 and cards with price $1100. Please fix it. Last fiddled with by LaurV on 2017-09-22 at 13:17

2017-10-04, 14:47	#11
VictordeHolland "Victor de Hollander" Aug 2011 the Netherlands 3²×131 Posts	I'm also in the market for a new GPU for: - TF - The occasional DoubleCheck - Racing games (Project Cars, F1 2016) - Roleplay/lounge games (Elder Scrolls, Kerbal Space Program) I'd like to get an ASUS card again, since I've had several years of good experience with them (a GTX470, GTX580, two HD7950 and a ROG Matrix 280X) Preferably I'd like to order it on a reliable hardware webshop in the Netherlands, that have them in store (Coolblue.nl and Azerty come to mind first), even if that means paying 10 or 20 euro extra. This would be the prices: ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1060 - €389 https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/5673...6g-gaming.html ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1070 - €519 https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/5479...8g-gaming.html ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1080 - €633 https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/5648...8g-gaming.html ASUS ROG STRIX GTX 1080ti - €839 https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/7499...1g-gaming.html Expected TF GHzdays/d (from http://www.mersenne.ca/mfaktc.php) GTX1060 - 459 GTX1070 - 689 GTX1080 - 980 GTX1080ti - 1263 CUDA cores GTX1060 - 1280 GTX1070 - 1920 GTX1080 - 2560 GTX1080ti - 3584 Memory Bandwidth GTX1060 - 192 GB/s GTX1070 - 256 GB/s GTX1080 - 320 GB/s GTX1080ti - 484 GB/s TDP (W) GTX1060 - 120 GTX1070 - 150 GTX1080 - 180 GTX1080ti - 250 GHzdayd / TDP(W) GTX1060 - 3.8 GTX1070 - 4.6 GTX1080 - 5.4 GTX1080ti - 5.1 Energy costs per kWh (in €) 0.06280 + 0.12257 + 0.00895 = 0.19432 (at night 23:00-07:00) 0.08069 + 0.12257 + 0.00895 = 0.21221 (rest of the day) (0.19432* 8 hours + 0.21221 * 16hours) / 24 hours = 0.206246 2 year running cost electricity (TDP/10000.206246243652years) GTX1060 - 433.61 GTX1070 - 542.02 GTX1080 - 650.42 GTX1080ti - 903.36 Already owned: ASUS HD7950 - 505.88 ASUS GTX580 - 881.68 GHzdays per day / Total Cost (initial cost+ 2y electricity) GTX1060 - 459 / (389 + 433.61) = 0.558 GTX1070 - 689 / (519 + 542.02) = 0.649 GTX1080 - 980 / (633 + 650.42) = 0.763 GTX1080ti - 1263 / (839 + 903.36) = 0.725 Already owned: ASUS HD7950 - 308 / (0+ 505.88) = 0.609 ASUS GTX580 - 433 / (0 + 881.68) = 0.491 So the GTX1060 is not really a good option, since my already owned HD7950 outperforms it in terms of GHzdays/€ . I've stopped running the GTX580 for some time now and these numbers support that decision. The GTX1080 has the best performance/€ on paper followed by the GTX1080ti. I probably don't really need the performance of a 1080(ti) for the games I play, but at least I can now justify spending the extra money . Last fiddled with by VictordeHolland on 2017-10-04 at 14:51 Reason: spelling

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
GTX 1080	storm5510	Hardware	31	2018-04-21 03:07
Recommended Cooling Unit	lukerichards	Hardware	15	2018-01-30 20:51
Recommended GTX 760 clockspeed?	UBR47K	GPU Computing	6	2015-12-20 17:22
Some recommended sequences	schickel	Aliquot Sequences	7	2009-07-25 10:00
Recommended TF bit levels for M(>10^8)	NBtarheel_33	Math	19	2008-11-03 17:19

2017-09-18, 19:50	#2
ATH Einyen Dec 2003 Denmark D6E₁₆ Posts	All of them has only DP performance at 1/32 of SP, so they will not be super for LL. They are so fast though, so they are still semi-decent I think? But it might be considered a "waste" using them for LL and "wasting" that high SP performance.