2013-04-17, 00:27 | #1 |
Jan 2013
2^{3}·7 Posts |
What Murphy score to expect or need [cado-nfs]
What Murphy score can I expect for a 181 digit composite? So far Cado reports going over 26% of the region it wants to search and I got one with 1.17*10E-14
It is by the way 40% better than most other found so far. Is this likely to be good enough? I now realize I bit off a little bit more than i can easily chew. I was fooled after observing that record factorizations were much much bigger, and when Dubslow factored a number I wanted of more than 212 digits in 10 days. I've been running polyselect already for more than a week on an 8core machine of 2008 vintage. :-( K |
2013-04-17, 00:40 | #2 |
"Serge"
Mar 2008
Phi(4,2^7658614+1)/2
5^{2}·373 Posts |
You would need ~2000 CPU-days to sieve this project, are you sure that you are ready for this? (it is roughly equivalent to a SNFS-270-digit project)
If CADO calcluated E-value is not very different from msieve's, then you should expect a much higher E, possibly 9e-14 ... 1e-13. |
2013-04-17, 15:02 | #3 |
Jan 2013
2^{3}×7 Posts |
Thanks, Sergei, actually i made a mistake caused by frustration. This is a 191 digit number actually, so it would take even longer than that. But it is a factor of M61^16+1 which is 294 digits. (a few factors of 103 digits in total already have been taken off by ECM). Because this was much more than the remaining composite number I thought the SNFS form of it would be useless. But thanks for pointing out that the SNFS equivalent difficulty is about the same.
Could you confirm for me that I should go for SNFS which comes from the 294 digit parent vs GNFS with 191 digits. Does it matter that 294 > 280 ? If I get totally frustrated at some point I may ask people to help sieving, but for now I will put effort to make sure I undertsand what I'm doing, and also try obtain some cpu's. Last fiddled with by kosta on 2013-04-17 at 15:03 |
2013-04-17, 17:30 | #4 |
"Serge"
Mar 2008
Phi(4,2^7658614+1)/2
5^{2}·373 Posts |
191-digit GNFS is better than the 294-digit SNFS. It's a GNFS job.
You would expect a poly with E ~= 2e-14 for this input. Sieving would take ~6000 CPU days and the matrix would be quite hard to finish on a home-computer (rough guess is that less than 16Gb won't work). This would be a project of the distributed type. |
Thread Tools | |
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
What to expect from GTX1080 for ECM? | fivemack | GPU Computing | 10 | 2016-05-11 09:07 |
Murphy's Law and other tools | Uncwilly | Lounge | 5 | 2014-07-07 22:36 |
Bug in top5000's score page? | MooooMoo | No Prime Left Behind | 3 | 2009-06-10 11:51 |
Murphy's law in full effect against me | JuanTutors | Lounge | 3 | 2007-06-15 16:42 |
primes to expect per k? | roger | Riesel Prime Search | 4 | 2007-04-29 04:29 |