20170123, 21:29  #1 
Jan 2017
2_{10} Posts 
sum and product  advanced
Hope this is the right place for a puzzle, maybe you enjoy.
Possibly an unknown version of the impossible puzzle. Let a and b be integers in the range of 2 to 1000 and a>=b. Seth got the sum, Paul got the product and Quinn the quotient. Paul: I do not know the two numbers. Seth: I knew that. Quinn: I've got a whole number. Paul: Still don't know them. Seth: Don't know the exact numbers yet. Quinn: No clue. Sigh! Seth: Now, I know them! Paul: Didn't know them until Seth's statement, but now i've got them too. 
20170123, 22:03  #2  
"Forget I exist"
Jul 2009
Dartmouth NS
2×5^{2}×13^{2} Posts 
Quote:
Paul's first comment says he doesn't know so there are multiple ways to get the product so a!=b except if they are a composite number. The fact that Quinn got a whole number shows that b divides into a therefore paul has a product x*b^2 this helps in the sense it deletes products that pass a squarefree test ( aka the distinct semiprimes etc.) edit: Seth's later statement about not knowing the exact numbers yet could hint that the sum has multiple factors as does x*b+b = (x+1)*(b) we could conclude that x+1 isn't a perfect power of b from this perhaps. or that b is not a perfect power of (x+1) also the fact that Quinn doesn't know shows that x is not unique to a and b ( could rule out quite a few values of x=1000/2=500 for example) it tells us a range for x.anyways for now I might stop to think about it more instead of editing my post Last fiddled with by science_man_88 on 20170123 at 22:24 

20170124, 21:20  #3 
Jan 2017
2 Posts 
You are right. Could a moderator please move this thread?

Thread Tools  
Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Advanced round off checking  wingman99  Information & Answers  3  20170218 05:47 
Advanced edit window  10metreh  Forum Feedback  6  20120713 23:26 
Advanced Options Ver 24.14  Unregistered  Information & Answers  2  20080223 20:23 
Ask an Advanced Algebra question.  wreck  Homework Help  8  20071016 00:49 
CPU Priority (advanced menu)  Software  7  20020924 23:54 