mersenneforum.org I have to prove everything
 Register FAQ Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

 2016-03-18, 03:10 #1 PawnProver44     "NOT A TROLL" Mar 2016 California 197 Posts I have to prove everything I was asked to prove every statement I made on mersenneforum.org and I really don't know where to start. I probably owe all of you a ton of proofs anyways.
 2016-03-18, 03:20 #2 retina Undefined     "The unspeakable one" Jun 2006 My evil lair 2×3×7×149 Posts I don't see the problem. If you make a claim be prepared to prove it. Otherwise your claim has no basis to stand upon. BTW: Did you know the moon is made of green cheese? And the Earth is flat Yeah, it's true. Just thought I'd let you know. You can all thank me later.
 2016-03-18, 03:41 #3 Uncwilly 6809 > 6502     """"""""""""""""""" Aug 2003 101×103 Posts 22·37·67 Posts Don't forget to show your work and/or tell us about the factoring work you have done on numbers that you claim might be prime. If you claim that a number is prime and have not found suitable factoring data or have not personally invested at least a solid day of GPU time (or maybe a week's worth of a quad core CPU time) factoring it, your claim is likely to fall on deaf ears. Also, what about P-1 factoring? Last fiddled with by Uncwilly on 2016-03-18 at 03:44
 2016-03-18, 06:26 #4 danaj   "Dana Jacobsen" Feb 2011 Bangkok, TH 32·101 Posts I hate to be pedantic (amusing though it is in this thread), but wouldn't claims of "a number is prime" be better served by running compositeness tests and/or showing proofs of primality, instead of factoring attempts? Knowing how to use Pari/GP, PFGW, and Primo seem like good starts for computational tools for primality related subjects. Last fiddled with by danaj on 2016-03-18 at 06:28 Reason: clarify tools are for primality, factoring would add some more (yafu and gmp-ecm, to name two)
 2016-03-18, 07:27 #5 ATH Einyen     Dec 2003 Denmark 3,163 Posts Just avoid starting posts with "This has never been considered before...." because then you are almost certain to be wrong right away, and people tend to ignore the rest of the post.
2016-03-18, 13:04   #6
science_man_88

"Forget I exist"
Jul 2009
Dumbassville

26×131 Posts

Quote:
 Originally Posted by PawnProver44 I was asked to prove every statement I made on mersenneforum.org and I really don't know where to start. I probably owe all of you a ton of proofs anyways.
start with at least supporting evidence ( as that's the minimum most people will want if you make a claim). I gave you the link to the wikipedia about mathematical proofs I technically even gave a counterproof to one of your statements by PM.

2016-03-18, 13:07   #7
science_man_88

"Forget I exist"
Jul 2009
Dumbassville

26×131 Posts

Quote:
 Originally Posted by danaj I hate to be pedantic (amusing though it is in this thread), but wouldn't claims of "a number is prime" be better served by running compositeness tests and/or showing proofs of primality, instead of factoring attempts? Knowing how to use Pari/GP, PFGW, and Primo seem like good starts for computational tools for primality related subjects.
ah but the size and type of the number in questions makes the LL the primality/compositeness test and the exponent is too large for it to run practically at last I think ( and yes I know I made a statement I can't prove) ( both for time and size of computations I think) therefore trial factoring is the easiest way. ( the exponent in questions is over the square root of M127).

Last fiddled with by science_man_88 on 2016-03-18 at 13:11

2016-03-18, 18:08   #8
danaj

"Dana Jacobsen"
Feb 2011
Bangkok, TH

16158 Posts

Quote:
 Originally Posted by science_man_88 ah but the size and type of the number in questions makes the LL the primality/compositeness test and the exponent is too large for it to run practically at last I think ( and yes I know I made a statement I can't prove) ( both for time and size of computations I think) therefore trial factoring is the easiest way. ( the exponent in questions is over the square root of M127).
Ah right, for huge Mersenne numbers (I was thinking of some of the other threads). Ucwilly's comment makes more sense now, especially with the "might be prime." You get "it's not trivially composite, even for some pretty large values of trivial."

This forum is different in that it is a bit specialized and the members try to keep the content quality high. It's very easy for forums to degenerate into places full of "my 5th attempt at a 1 page proof of Beals / FLT / RH" or "How do you factor ginormous numbers like 170540451098587 in less than a month?" or "OMG, I've solved primes! They're all 6k +/- 1!"

2016-03-18, 19:02   #9
EdH

"Ed Hall"
Dec 2009

22·11·89 Posts

Quote:
 Originally Posted by retina ... Did you know the moon is made of green cheese?
After 25000 years, we finally were able to seek this cheese, even landing men there from 1969-1972. But alas, no one found any and we haven't set foot there since...
Quote:
 Originally Posted by retina And the Earth is flat Yeah, it's true. Just thought I'd let you know. You can all thank me later.
This was the truth. It was only a (relatively) short time ago that we stitched together all the edges and rounded out the surface.

2016-03-18, 19:38   #10
retina
Undefined

"The unspeakable one"
Jun 2006
My evil lair

625810 Posts

Quote:
 Originally Posted by EdH After 25000 years, we finally were able to seek this cheese, even landing men there from 1969-1972. But alas, no one found any and we haven't set foot there since...
You must have missed "Wallace and Gromit: A Grand Day Out". Video evidence. So it must be true.
Quote:
 Originally Posted by EdH This was the truth. It was only a (relatively) short time ago that we stitched together all the edges and rounded out the surface.
It's turtles all the way down.

2016-03-18, 23:17   #11
only_human

"Gang aft agley"
Sep 2002

375410 Posts

Quote:
 Originally Posted by EdH After 25000 years, we finally were able to seek this cheese, even landing men there from 1969-1972. But alas, no one found any and we haven't set foot there since...
Actually the moon was an early contestant of the Cheese-Rolling At Cooper's Hill In Gloucestershire - as everyone knows.

 Similar Threads Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post George M Miscellaneous Math 5 2018-01-02 11:11 siegert81 Math 2 2014-11-19 10:24 Damian Math 31 2008-10-03 02:11 MatWur-S530113 Math 4 2007-06-27 05:35 mdjvz Software 4 2003-09-28 17:13

All times are UTC. The time now is 08:22.

Sat Sep 18 08:22:04 UTC 2021 up 57 days, 2:51, 0 users, load averages: 1.15, 1.38, 1.45